The first seven Tournament MVPs in Battle of the Balls history were determined by the players of the winning team. The format of the award was changed for Battle of the Balls VIII when it was decided by the tournament organizer. District Five goaltender Stefan Plantinga is the lone player to win the award on multiple occassions, having won three times (BOTB III, IV, IX).
 |
| Stefan Plantinga district five | botb ix |
 |
| BATTLE OF THE BALLS VIII jeff maas and simon neufeld | tuesday night |
 |
| BATTLE OF THE BALLS VII dave wright | district five |
 |
| BATTLE OF THE BALLS V harold cecchetti | district five |
 |
| BATTLE OF THE BALLS IV stefan plantinga | district five |
 |
| BATTLE OF THE BALLS III stefan plantinga | district five |
 |
| HOLIDAY CUP 2009 joel pel | team vcs |
 |
| GBFFHT 2008 aaron gysbers | team vcs |